Curating Curation
March 14, 2012
This post was composed over at Storify and exported here.
-
Because of stuff I’ve been doing at work lately, and some recent conversations at code4lib in Seattle I’ve been getting more and more interested in archival description and the Web. When I first ran across Storify it seemed like it might provide some useful user interface ideas that could be used in archival description. I’ve been thinking how web content such as Wikipedia, authority records, etc could be easily referenced while composing descriptive text about a collection. And once this content has been referenced how can it be baked in so that the content is usable in the future?Recently I stumbled upon (pun intended) a topic to try out Storify: the emerging conversation going on in Twitter and in blogs about Web curation. I know how meta right? As a software developer working in the cultural heritage sector my interest in curation has already been piqued for some time. But until just now I was completely oblivious to the emerging debate about new mechanics for expressing attribution on the Web. I actually ran across it because this tweet from Matt Langer flitted across my TweetDeck:
-
Share
-
ShareStop Calling It Curation1 day ago … Stop Calling It Curation Imagine, if you will, a world in which Richard Seaver or Robert Gottlieb had stomped their feet …
-
The tweet led me over to his blog post on Gizmodo, which rankled my anti-authoritarian sensibilities a bit. This statement in particular got the blood pumping:“Curation” is an act performed by people with PhDs in art history; the business in which we’re all engaged when we’re tossing links around on the Internet is simple “sharing”.But getting into an argument about the semantics of “curation” doesn’t seem particularly appealing or useful. One of the reasons why I think “curation” works for Curate Camp, International Journal of Digital Curation and elsewhere is that it has somewhat loose semantics, which allows useful collaboration and conversation to spring up around it. Saying you need a PhD to do curation makes me mad, probably because I don’t have one. Maybe it was a joke. Anyhow, moving on.Speaking of semantics Langer goes on to say:But we should not delude ourselves for a moment into bestowing any special significance on this, because when we do this thing that so many of us like to call “curation” we’re not providing any sort of ontology or semantic continuity beyond that of our own whimsy or taste or desire.
I think Langer under-estimates how a little semantics can go a long way. Exhibit A: PageRank. Exhibit B: Microformats. I have to thank Langer’s piece for drawing me into the discussion more. I’ll chalk it up to another sign that every good consumer technology has haters. -
Share
-
So it was time to actually look at the Curator’s Code itself. The instructions are pretty short and brief: use “via” and “HT” or their unicode equivalents ᔥ and ↬ respectively. I’ve already been sub-consciously using “via” for some time now, so a little bit of discussion about seems like a good idea.
-
ShareIntroducing The Curator's Code: A Standard for Honoring Attribution …4 days ago … As both a consumer and curator of information, I spend a great deal of time thinking about the architecture of knowledge…
-
Maria Popova has a more detailed description of the rationale behind the use of unicode characters. Strangely the discussion didn’t mention what I thought was going to be the primary reason for them: brevity. There have been similar efforts to use special unicode characters on Twitter (where real estate is scarce) before. There are already bookmarklets for easily creating links that use the correct unicode glyphs. But this led me to another post:
-
ShareIt's not curation or aggregation, it's just how the Internet works …It's not curation or aggregation, it's just how the Internet works. By Mathew Ingram Mar. 13, 2012, 12:43pm PT 2 Comments · Twe…
-
Ingram’s essential point is that if the past is any guide the Web will route around efforts to control the way citations are made, and more importantly that:… we already have a tool for providing credit to the original source — it’s called the hyperlink.
Which I strongly agree with. That being said we have seen some pretty wide deployment and use of mechanisms like rel=license microformat for expressing the license for a piece of content. Of course typed links between resources is nothing new. It has been the much muddied central message of the Semantic Web movement. -
Sharehope the #curation community supports upcoming #w3c spec on provenance - signal attribution, quotation and source w3.org/blog/SW/2011/10/23/…
-
Groth mentions some serious work that has been going on at the W3C for expressing provenance on the Web. The challenge here I think is to have something with the simplicity of a microformat for expressing these semantics. Perhaps some additions to the Link Relations Registry that would let HTML authors use rel=“via” or whatever…This seems a bit more sensible to me than expecting people to all use the same obscure unicode characters at any rate.
-
I guess the back story here is that a lot of this discussion is the result of discussions going on at SXSW.
-
ShareSXSW Sketch Reportage Bulletin 06: Curate or be curated. blog.fueledbycoffee.com/ta… #SXSW #sketchnotes cc: (brainpicker?) (david2n?) (maxlinsky?)
-
Share
-
And has been amplified by venerable institutions like the the New York Times:
-
ShareGuidelines Proposed for Content Aggregation Online - NYTimes.com2 days ago … “What makes the Internet magical to me is that it is a place of radical discovery,” said Ms. Popova, who describes herse…
-
and The Atlantic:
-
ShareThe Curator's Guide to the Galaxy - Megan Garber - Technology …2 days ago … How to steal other people's ideas (without being a jerk about it)
-
And of course there is the requisite (and much welcomed) humorous take on the whole thing:
-
ShareNine Additional Symbols for the Curator's Code | The New York …This weekend's biggest Internet news involves The Curator's Code, a new system “for honoring the creative and intellectual labo…
-
I for one hope the topic of curation and the Web continues. And in other news, Storify is kind of fun. I’m going to test out the export feature after I hit publish.